Okay but remember how in AA3 if you present Mia’s profile to Gumshoe, he gets all “Mia? Of course I knew Mia! We all knew Mia down at the precinct! She was an amazing woman, pal, a real loss to this city! ...It’s just raining on my face, okay?!" Retconned headcanon that he jumps on this incredibly flimsy evidence because he’s really upset and not thinking clearly.